As an omnivore, I’m probably going to be told that I can’t talk like this, yet I’m going to anyway.

Lately I have been getting the feeling that proselytizing vegans are the more artificial of our species, and have their mental roots in some good old-fashioned monotheistic fundamentalism.

It seems that they are inclined to view the eating of meat as somewhat grubbier than the eating of plants – and this is leaving out entirely the question of factory farming and intolerable conditions for our meat animals, which is an important point on its own but which does not seem entirely to inform the evangelical zeal of many vegans and some vegetarians.

I have a huge issue with how we raise much of our meat, but those objections could be equally raised with regard to how we farm our plants. As long as I want to remain incarnate, I have to eat.

In all of nature, humans are the only ones who profess an emotional objection to meat-eating. This tells me that we are losing, or have lost, our connection to the Earth in a fundamental way.

The bird pulling the worm out of the ground has a very good idea of the habits and living conditions of worms. The tiger knows precisely how her prey will react to the sight of her. That is how they feed – by knowing, in an un-intellectual manner, what it means to be the prey animal. The skin mite has an appreciation of my body which I could only dream of consciously matching.

This behaviour is also known as empathy.

Many of us humans no longer have empathy with the living creatures – animal or plant – which we consume.

There is a slight but noticeable tendency to consider all “cruelty” as Bad, and all sympathy as Good, in a dualistic moral set we seem to have inherited from the Middle Eastern religions.

For me, sympathy is a shallow and painful version of the knowing of another. Empathy, or maybe compassion, is the real McCoy.

So before you pick up your knife and fork, it would help to pause for a moment. Become the animal or plant whose substance you are about to ingest. In all its terror. In all its resignation. In all its knowing of the reality of the Web, which is not a chain or a pyramid, but something vastly more complex.

Do not remove yourself from its environment. It is all we have, really.


5 responses to “Empathy

  1. I was just thinking about this the other day and considering revisiting the topic on Panthea. Nicely put. Lisa@Panthea


  2. I think that it and religion has common roots rather than one following on the other. Some people love being told what to do, they have no will, and some of them will go all in in an attempt to cover what they do not possess with a lot of bluster.

    Back in the day there was only bearded big brother up in the clouds to profess your everlasting ignorance to. These days there’s a pre-cast belief system for every bit of consciousness they don’t possess.

    They call it “impact-free living”. One day they will hire an efficiency consultant consultant and he will shorten it to “death”.


  3. One major difference if that in eating animals you are eating both the animals and all the plants they had to eat, so no matter how you cut it the impact is greater.

    I’m not a vegan, btw, and agree there can be some religious type zealotry, butt here’s not a belief I haven’t seen accompanied by zealotry.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s