The Rehabilitation of a Word

Recently, we in South Africa have seen a fair amount of discussion over the usage of the word witch.

Many non-Pagans in this country have been in the habit of tossing the word around to indicate a person, usually female although sometimes male or a child, who produces malefica .Sometimes an isInyanga or iSangoma is called in, particularly those specializing in witch finding , to point out the presumed witch.

I don’t think I need to say that those pointed out are never, in actual fact, witches. They have no knowledge of the techniques and rituals involved in causing a drought, for example, or the sickness of somebody’s child. They are known to us today by another word, one which has rung down the centuries in bloody array: scapegoat.

It’s also probably not necessary to emphasise that the only people in the affected community who have the magical knowledge are those involved in placing the blame on others. It’s quite ironic and also infinitely sad.

We have been advocating the reclamation of this word for some time now – only to face opposition from the darndest quarter. It seems that there exist some Pagans, notably South African, who have gone to some lengths recently to make the reclamation look like an exercise in selfish human-rights trampling.
Their argument runs something like this: bad muthi, use of human body parts, etc are linked to black African ‘witches’ and so we , as purveyors of purity and light, should be using some other name.

Right on. Let’s just leave those innocent women to be scapegoated by that word because we don’t want to get our images tarnished. Never mind that it is in fact a criminal, and often a criminal wearing the guise of a Sangoma or Nyanga who is righteously pointing out the scapegoats while dealing in body parts him or herself.

Another argument to surface recently has been constructed around the perceived harm of the use of the word ‘witch’, the proponents arguing that, just as we no longer sanction the use of derogatory words which were used in the Apartheid regime as denigrating and belittling people-especially people of any other colour than ‘white’– so we should not be seeking to use the word ‘witch’ for fear of hurting other people.

This is a fine specimen of a strawman argument. The proponents of this line of reasoning neglect to remember that those of us who suffered under the repulsive derogatory racist words were given no choice in the matter. Now we, as the witches (there are no other adherents- only more scapegoats) freely desire to attach this label to ourselves. In pride. Just as, in another country and another century, Americans of African descent proudly reclaimed the word ‘Nigger’.
Advertisements

7 responses to “The Rehabilitation of a Word

  1. I take witches with a grain of salt as I know that they have no more mystical powers than I do. My favorite witches of course are loving ones, I wouldn’t mind living with one. Of course, I will still have to take the garbage out because her wiggling her nose isn’t going to get it out. 🙂

    Like

  2. Well, I am a witch. I can’t call myself something else because a witch is what I am. I like it, actually, for all the very reasons that it upsets and frightens some other people. A Druidess once explained to me her understanding of the difference between witches and Druids. Druids had laws, and organizations, and structures and functioned within the power structure of Celtic society. Witches were those wild women living on the outskirts of town who didn’t follow society’s rules and who knew things that made them dangerous. I think that’s about right. I’m a witch.

    Like

  3. …and so am I, Hecate.And so, if we can believe the ad-hoc polls we’ve been taking, are quite a number of SA Pagans.About 95% of SA Pagans are in favour of trying, as a body, to reclaim the word.But-of all travesties!- certain agenda-laden parties want us to voteon the subject, atthe first SA Pagan Conference coming up this weekend.The SAPRA executive will be vetoing the vote.Love,Terri in Joburg

    Like

  4. Mary L A…. Because Terri hasn’t asked me to go away. :-)Besides, everything is about sexism and has nothing to do with material things, in case you haven’t noticed. Hugs.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s